Native
Americans
have
often
held
intersex,
androgynous
people,
feminine
males
and
masculine
females
in
high
respect.
The
most
common
term
to
define
such
persons
today
is
to
refer
to
them
as
"two-spirit"
people,
but
in
the
past
feminine
males
were
sometimes
referred
to
as
"berdache"
by
early
French
explorers
in
North
America,
who
adapted a Persian word "bardaj", meaning an intimate male friend.
Because
these
androgynous
males
were
commonly
married
to
a
masculine
man,
or
had
sex
with
men,
and
the
masculine
females
had
feminine
women
as
wives,
the
term
berdache
had
a
clear
homosexual
conno-
tation.
Both
the
Spanish
settlers
in
Latin
America
and
the
English
colonists
in
North
America
condemned
them
as
"sodomites".
Rather
than
emphasising
the
homosexuality
of
these
persons,
however,
many
Native
Americans
focused
on
their
spiritual
gifts.
American
Indian
traditionalists,
even
today,
tend
to
see
a
person's
basic
character as a reflection of their spirit.
Since
everything
that
exists
is
thought
to
come
from
the
spirit
world,
androgynous
or
transgender
persons
are
seen
as
doubly
blessed,
having
both
the
spirit
of
a
man
and
the
spirit
of
a
woman.
Thus,
they
are
honoured
for
having
two
spirits,
and
are
seen
as
more
spiritually
gifted
than
the
typical
masculine male or feminine female.
Therefore,
many
Native
American
religions,
rather
than
stigmatising
such
persons,
often
looked
to
them
as
religious
leaders
and
teachers.
Quite
similar
religious
traditions
existed
among
the
native
peoples
of
Siberia
and
many
parts
of
Central
and
southeast
Asia.
Since
the
ancestors
of
Native
Americans
migrated
from
Siberia
over
20,000
years
ago,
and
since
reports
of
highly
respected
androgynous
persons
have
been
noted
among
indigenous
Americans
from
Alaska
to
Chile,
androgyny
seems
to
be
quite
ancient
among
humans.
Rather
than
the
physical
body,
Native
Americans
emphasised
a
person's
"spirit",
or
character,
as
being
most
important.
Instead
of
seeing
two-spirit
persons
as
transsexuals
who
try
to
make
themselves
into
"the
opposite
sex",
it
is
more
accurate
to
understand
them
as
individuals who take on a gender status that is different from both men and women.
This
alternative
gender
status
offers
a
range
of
possibilities,
from
slightly
effeminate
males
or
masculine
females,
to
androgynous
or
transgender
persons,
to
those
who
completely cross-dress and act as the other gender.
The
emphasis
of
Native
Americans
is
not
to
force
every
person
into
one
box,
but
to
allow for the reality of diversity in gender and sexual identities.
Most
of
the
evidence
for
respectful
two-spirit
traditions
is
focused
on
the
native
peoples
of
the
Plains,
the
Great
Lakes,
the
Southwest,
and
California.
With
over
a
thousand
vastly
different
cultural
and
linguistic
backgrounds,
it
is
important
not
to
overgeneralise for the indigenous peoples of North America.
Some
documentary
sources
suggest
that
a
minority
of
societies
treated
two-spirit
persons
dis-
respectfully,
by
kidding
them
or
dis-
couraging
children
from
taking
on
a
two-spirit
role.
However,
many
of
the
documents
that
report
negative
reactions
are
themselves
suspect,
and
should
be
evaluated
critically
in
light
of
the
preponderance
of
evidence
that
suggests
a
respectful
attitude.
Some
European
commentators,
from
early
frontier
explorers
to
modern
anthropologists,
also
were
influenced
by
their
own
homophobic
prejudices to distort native attitudes.
Two-spirit
people
were
respected
by
native
societies
not
only
due
to
religious
attitudes,
but
also
because
of
practical
concerns.
Because
their
gender
roles
involved
a
mixture
of
both
masculine
and
feminine
traits,
two-spirit
persons
could
do
both
the
work
of
men
and
of
women.
They
were
often
considered
to
be
hard
workers
and
artistically
gifted,
of
great
value
to
their
extended families and community.
Among
some
groups,
such
as
the
Navajo,
a
family
was
believed
to
be
economically
benefited
by
having
a
"nadleh"
(literally
translated
as
"one
who
is
transformed")
androgynous
person
as
a
relative.
Two-spirit
persons
assisted
their
siblings'
children
and
took
care
of
elderly
relatives,
and
often
served
as
adoptive
parents
for
homeless
children.
A
feminine
male
who
preferred
to
do
women's
work
(gathering
wild
plants
or
farming
domestic
plants)
was
logically
expected
to
marry
a
masculine
male,
who
did
men's
work
(hunting
and
warfare).
Because
a
family
needed
both
plant
foods
and
meat,
a
masculine
female
hunter,
in
turn,
usually
married
a
feminine
female,
to
provide
these
complementary
gender
roles
for
economic
survival.
The
gender-conforming
spouse
of
two-spirit
people
did
not
see
themselves as "homosexual" or as anything other than "normal".
In
the
20th-century,
as
homophobic
European
Christian
influences
increased
among
many
Native
Americans,
respect
for
same-sex
love
and
for
androgynous
persons
greatly
declined.
T
wo-spirit
people
w
ere
often
forced,
either
by
government
officials,
Christian missionaries or their own community, to conform to standard gender roles.
Some,
who
could
not
conform,
either
went
underground
or
committed
suicide.
With
the
imposition
of
Euro-American
marriage
laws,
same-sex
marriages
between
two-
spirit people and their spouses were no longer legally recognised.
But
with
the
revitalisation
of
Native
American
"red
power"
cultural
pride
since
the
60s,
and
the
rise
of
gay
and
lesbian
liberation
movements
at
the
same
time,
a
new
respect
for androgyny started slowly re-emerging among American Indian people.
Because
of
this
tradition
of
respect,
in
the
90s
many
gay
and
lesbian
Native
American
activists
in
the
United
States
and
Canada
rejected
the
French
word
berdache
in
favour of the term two-spirit people to describe themselves.
Many
non-American
Indians
have
incorporated
knowledge
of
Native
American
two-
spirit
traditions
into
their
increasing
acceptance
of
same-sex
love,
androgyny
and
transgender
diversity.
Native
American
same-sex
marriages
have
been
used
as
a
model
for
legalising
same-sex
marriages,
and
the
spiritual
gifts
of
androgynous
persons have started to become more recognised.
Walter
L.Williams
is
the
author
of
The
Spirit
and
the
Flesh
(Boston:
Beacon
Press)
and
is
Professor
of
Anthropology,
History
and
Gender
Studies
at
the
University
of
Southern
California.
His most recent book, Two Spirits: A Story Of Life With The Navajo is out now
.